Determining impact and return: How now?


30th May 2016

Determining impact and return: How now?


30th May 2016

Determining impact and return: How now?

How to measure the impact and return on investment of community/social programmes has plagued industry practitioners for a long time.

The Investment Impact Index™ was developed as a uniquely African methodology to solve this problem.

Until now there has been a lot of focus on monitoring and evaluating the outputs and outcomes of social, community and enterprise development programmes. Moving to the next stage – measuring the impact and return of development programmes – has been more problematic.

Although 90% of all funders and intermediaries measure their work through quantitative assessment and 75% of all funders and intermediaries claim they have the capacity to measure their work and 58% of all funders and intermediaries have a framework to measure their work:

  • Only 24% of all funders and intermediaries have a data evaluation framework.
  • Only 25% of all funders and intermediaries have an evaluation plan.
  • Only 5% of all funders collect qualitative date.

Research evidence suggests that it is because:

Funders:

  1. Don’t have clearly defined indicators to measure impact and return.
  2. Don’t have clearly defined theories of grantmaking, practice and change to be able to measure substantial change.

Development organisations:

  1. Don’t have the resources, skills or capabilities to extend current M&E practice to the next level.
  2. Have more pressing needs, such as fundraising and marketing.

This presentation was delivered at the Sustainable Brands Conference in Africa. The presentation details specifically how the Investment Impact Index works, how to define impact and return on investment as well as what indicators and aspects of impact to consider. It also shares lessons learned over an extended 5-year period.

Related Articles


WHAT WE DO

The success of social innovation doesn't depend on just one thing... That's why we have a targeted approach and method to ensuring real, widespread and inclusive development and economic growth. Learn more about how we do what we do;...

SHARING KNOWLEDGE

With over 20 years in the world of social innovation and transformation… we’ve learned quite a bit… And we believe that knowledge is a social currency that is best shared. Visit nextgeneration.co.za to learn more about social...

ANNUAL REPORT FORESIGHT

Next Generation Consultants makes some exciting predictions about what could be shaking up the social investment and development industry sectors in the year ahead, taking a closer look at the future of social enterprises, new...

WHO WE ARE

Next Generation Consultants imagine the world the way it could be… and then we get to work. We partner with companies across Africa, focusing on sustainable development through social innovation to realise the dreams made possible...

ANNUAL REPORT HINDSIGHT

For the past 15 years, Next Generation Consultants has published an annual guide on the trends and forecasts for the social investment and development sectors in Africa. We’d like to share some findings from our report for 2018 in 3...

MEASURING IMPACT

Some people say success can’t be measured… We’re not those people. Our published book, The Investment Impact Index, explores our matrix for quantifying and qualifying the impact of social investment and development. It not only...