Determining impact and return: How now?


Determining impact and return: How now?


30th May 2016

Determining impact and return: How now?

How to measure the impact and return on investment of community/social programmes has plagued industry practitioners for a long time.

The Investment Impact Index™ was developed as a uniquely African methodology to solve this problem.

Until now there has been a lot of focus on monitoring and evaluating the outputs and outcomes of social, community and enterprise development programmes. Moving to the next stage – measuring the impact and return of development programmes – has been more problematic.

Although 90% of all funders and intermediaries measure their work through quantitative assessment and 75% of all funders and intermediaries claim they have the capacity to measure their work and 58% of all funders and intermediaries have a framework to measure their work:

  • Only 24% of all funders and intermediaries have a data evaluation framework.
  • Only 25% of all funders and intermediaries have an evaluation plan.
  • Only 5% of all funders collect qualitative date.

Research evidence suggests that it is because:

Funders:

  1. Don’t have clearly defined indicators to measure impact and return.
  2. Don’t have clearly defined theories of grantmaking, practice and change to be able to measure substantial change.

Development organisations:

  1. Don’t have the resources, skills or capabilities to extend current M&E practice to the next level.
  2. Have more pressing needs, such as fundraising and marketing.

This presentation was delivered at the Sustainable Brands Conference in Africa. The presentation details specifically how the Investment Impact Index works, how to define impact and return on investment as well as what indicators and aspects of impact to consider. It also shares lessons learned over an extended 5-year period.

Related Articles


IMPACT AT SCALE

Development work is hard. Making change happen at scale is complex and there is not a linear path. Yet, achieving impact at scale is a goal many grantmakers, philanthropists, social and impact investors aim for – but this goal is not o...

5 Ways to increase your impact

Many investors, grantmakers, donors and philanthropists depend on their implementing partners to achieve their impact goals and objectives. Having a clear impact strategy, impact thesis and impact objectives will make achieving impact...

What do donors want?

When donors decide to contribute to a cause, they often seek specific benefits that go beyond mere financial support. Understanding these motivations can help impact organizations tailor their approaches to meet donor expectations...

Determining impact and return: How now?

How to measure the impact and return on investment of community/social programmes has plagued industry practitioners for a long time. The Investment Impact Index™ was developed as a uniquely African methodology to solve this problem. ...

A disrupted future

From here to there - and everything in between.Whether you are in health, education, youth, disability, empowerment, capacity building – it does not matter! • What will the sector look like post Covid?Download the report...

Diverse professionals touching hands around a table

Blended Finance

Innovative and blended finance as a route to greater social impact and sustainabilityThere are three ways in which private resources can be harnessed for meeting societal needs: Through charitable giving and philanthropy Through corporat...