Benefits and challenges of stakeholder engagement


Benefits and challenges of stakeholder engagement


1st June 2016

Benefits and challenges of stakeholder engagement

Stakeholder engagement is not a new concept. Recent reporting frameworks (GRI and IIRC) have however pushed the topic up the ladder of importance for companies, as it is a specific reporting requirement in order to develop and release sustainability and integration reports.

On the upside, reporting requires companies to report annually on stakeholder engagement activities, almost forcing the activity to be conducted at least once a year. On the downside, many reporting companies still confuse stakeholder engagement with other types of traditional communication activities such as marketing, promotions, sales talks or supplier conventions, or annual investor briefings.

Taking stakeholder concerns and interests into account can improve business relationships, which may: make it easier for a company to operate; lead to ideas for products or services that will address stakeholder needs; and allow the company to reduce costs and maximise value.

Sustainability and integrated reporting requires stakeholder engagement to:

  • Identify material risks and opportunities
  • Obtain input for organisational priorities and activities
  • Provide feedback on progress towards a more sustainable future

However, many companies miss the opportunity to use stakeholder engagement to:

  • Pool knowledge, experience and co-create solutions that addresses societal, industry and business issues
  • Develop new products and services or even enter new markets
  • Build collaborative partnerships and relationships that contribute to value creation (profitability)
  • Accurately estimate the power of collaboration within an industry or value chain, as many companies only focus on existing stakeholder groups such as customers, employees and investors.

Some considerations for more effective stakeholder engagement:

  • Ensure that the right stakeholders are identified. Stakeholders very seldom see themselves as neat little homogenous stakeholder groups. An NGO/activist group can provide valuable insight into various economic, social and environmental issues.
  • Furthermore, a concerted effort must be made to ensure that stakeholders are qualified to provide the right insight/feedback into a specific sustainability aspect. This may require capacitating stakeholders with the knowledge and skills to be able to engage.
  • Ensure that the right stakeholders are identified early enough to ensure that a variety of perceptions and inputs can be obtained that represents the views and opinions of a wide variety of stakeholders, as this will ensure balanced and fair representation of opinions on a specific subject matter. Companies should be cautious not to only engage stakeholders they have existing or good relationships with, but be resilient and courageous enough to listen to opposing and critical voices.
  • Ensure that engagement happens regularly (not just once a year) so that a variety of opinions, insights, knowledge and collaborations can be obtained and feedback can be provided on actions taken based on specific stakeholder requirements and expectations.
  • Sometimes it may be required that stakeholders and representatives of stakeholder groups be educated and trained in aspects of engagement.It is important to note that from a historic perspective worker representatives and unions enter engagement with a view to negotiate or communities enter engagements with a view to obtain development funding. As such, engagement objectives and outcome expectations of the engagement must be stated and agreed upfront to ensure successful outcomes for all parties concerned.
  • Specific and varied engagement strategies are required to deal with urban vs. rural stakeholder groups as well as other intrinsic qualities and characteristics of stakeholders to cater for unique local conditions such as gender and language and literacy issues.

Related Articles


Woman smiling in front of blue wall

Where is the good news? I need it today!

Working in the field of community development with both funders and their implementing partners I am constantly looking for innovative and creative ways to solve social issues. Because of the amount of research and benchmarking that I co...

Pensive woman looking out window

Failing at grantmaking?

Failing at grantmaking? Low impact and low return: Funders and grantmakers should be concernedAfter conducting numerous impact assessments for some of South Africa’s largest donors and grantmakers, Next Generation Consultants came up w...

Fingers touching a display that says "think differently"

Rethinking the funding of NGOs

The Next Generation Research Report 2020, Disruption with Impact dived deep into how the development sector, and how the funding of NGOs, is changing. Some of the most significant pressures that organisations face is the demand to become...

Hands holding a note that says ROI

Social value and return on investment

Lets talk about social return on investmentGrantmakers, donors and philanthropists want nothing else, but to make an impact with their investments.  So do companies, foundations and trusts.  And – if you are a more commercially incli...

Evidence of impact and return – 2015

This presentation was given at the Sustainable Brands Africa Conference in May 2016. It provides case studies and lessons learnt of conducting numerous impact assessments. It also provides advice of how to conduct impact assessments,...

Diverse professionals touching hands around a table

Blended Finance

Innovative and blended finance as a route to greater social impact and sustainabilityThere are three ways in which private resources can be harnessed for meeting societal needs: Through charitable giving and philanthropy Through corporat...

How to conduct stakeholder engagement

Strategies and techniques for improving relationships in the value chainCompanies globally are exposed to risk simply by engaging with other businesses, communities and governments. Companies are responsible for the products and services...

Common mistakes in stakeholder engagement

takeholder management can be an effective risk management tool.  But simply engaging for purposes of reporting or compliance and governance underestimates the real value of stakeholder engagement.  These days companies issuing sustaina...

Determining impact and return: How now?

How to measure the impact and return on investment of community/social programmes has plagued industry practitioners for a long time. The Investment Impact Index™ was developed as a uniquely African methodology to solve this problem. ...